CMS Unveils the CRUSH Rule, Promising $90 Billion in Fraud Savings as Improper Payments Climb to $112.9 Billion, and Medicare Advantage Insurers Carry Most of the Risk
The federal government is trying to stop paying first and asking questions later. On November 16, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released a proposed rule called the Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, or CRUSH, which the agency says could save taxpayers nearly $90 billion over the next decade, according to the HHS announcement. It landed the same day CMS put its estimate of improper payments for fiscal 2026 at about $112.9 billion, up from roughly $96.1 billion a year earlier, as Fierce Healthcare reported.
The proposal reaches across Medicare, Medicaid, the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) and the ACA Health Insurance Marketplace. For insurers, providers, medical-equipment suppliers and insurance brokers, it is one of the broadest program-integrity packages in years, and the bulk of the projected savings points at one industry: Medicare Advantage.
What the CRUSH Rule Would Change
CMS describes CRUSH as a standalone rule that moves fraud prevention to the front of the payment process. The main Medicare provisions, as laid out by HHS and Healthcare Finance News, include:
- Tougher Medicare Advantage audits. CMS would codify its approach to Risk Adjustment Data Validation (RADV) audits, which check whether the diagnoses insurers submit to raise risk scores are backed by medical records. It would extrapolate findings starting with payment year 2018 and would not apply a fee-for-service adjuster. The agency estimates this could recover an average of about $9 billion per payment year.
- Mandatory fraud reporting by plans. MA organizations and Part D sponsors would have to report suspected or substantiated fraud, waste and abuse. CMS said only 46% of Part C and D contracts voluntarily reported such referrals in 2025, and just 19% reported payment suspensions tied to credible fraud allegations.
- Enrollment screening for MA providers. Most providers and suppliers that bill Medicare Advantage plans would need to enroll in Original Medicare, so CMS can run identity checks, licensing reviews and site visits. Healthcare Finance News reports this would take effect two plan years after a final rule.
- A 30-day reporting clock. Providers would have to report every change to their Medicare enrollment information within 30 calendar days, and CMS would gain power to deny or revoke enrollment when it cannot verify owners or locations.
- Limits on aggressive marketing. The rule adds protections for seniors against unsolicited texts, social media messages, emails without an opt-out and door-to-door visits from medical supply companies.
On the Medicaid and CHIP side, states would collect National Provider Identifiers more consistently, expand ownership disclosures and fraud reporting, and face a 60-day deadline to report and return self-identified fee-for-service overpayments. Medicaid managed-care plans would have to report beneficiary deaths or address changes within 30 days. In the Marketplace, CMS wants authority to suspend agents and brokers immediately on credible allegations of abusive conduct and to restrict those with certain felony convictions or program exclusions, along with new safeguards against Marketplace system access from outside the United States.
The Numbers Behind the Push
CMS is pointing to recent results to justify the crackdown. The agency says Medicare program-integrity savings rose 59%, from $26.3 billion in fiscal 2024 to a record $41.9 billion in fiscal 2025, with a return of $22.30 for every dollar invested, according to the HHS release. Fierce Healthcare, citing the proposed rule, reports the new guardrails would cost the government about $378.5 million over ten years, a small figure next to the projected savings.
The improper-payment estimate shows why regulators feel pressure. Per Fierce Healthcare, the fiscal 2026 figures break down to $34 billion in Original Medicare, $23.9 billion in Medicare Part C, $5.2 billion in Part D, $46.8 billion in Medicaid, $2.3 billion in CHIP and $830.4 million in Marketplace premium tax credit advance payments. CMS notes that improper payments are not the same as fraud; they include administrative errors and underpayments, and the latest data covers claims from mid-2024 to mid-2025, before many of its newer initiatives took effect.
It is also worth keeping the headline number in perspective. As Healthcare Finance News points out, the nearly $90 billion is a projection, not money already recovered. Public comments are open until January 19, 2027, and the final rule could look different.
Why It Matters for Business
Medicare Advantage insurers face the largest financial exposure. Codifying RADV extrapolation back to payment year 2018, without a fee-for-service adjuster, turns an audit method insurers have long contested into regulation. For publicly traded MA carriers, that raises the odds of larger clawbacks and makes coding practices a board-level risk rather than a back-office detail. Expect heavy lobbying and legal pushback during the comment period.
Providers get a heavier compliance load. A 30-day window for every enrollment change, plus a requirement that MA-billing providers enroll in Original Medicare, adds paperwork for physician groups, home-health agencies and suppliers that have worked mainly through MA networks. Practices that change ownership, add locations or bring in new managers will need cleaner processes to avoid enrollment denials or revocations.
Brokers, marketers and equipment suppliers are squarely in the frame. Faster suspension powers and new limits on unsolicited outreach could reshape how agencies sell Marketplace and Medicare products. Healthcare Finance News notes that CMS barred 11 medical-equipment suppliers tied to more than $3.4 billion in suspected fraudulent billing in September, a sign the agency is already acting on this front.
There is also an opportunity. Rules like these tend to create demand for identity verification, ownership-data tools, claims analytics and compliance automation. Health-tech and services firms that help plans and providers prove their data is clean stand to benefit, while organizations with weak documentation face real cash risk. CMS has also said it intends to do program-integrity rulemaking on an annual basis going forward, per Fierce Healthcare, so this is likely the first of several rounds.
The Bottom Line
CRUSH signals that Washington wants to stop healthcare fraud at the front door rather than chase it afterward. If finalized close to its current form, it would tighten audits on Medicare Advantage insurers, add new reporting duties for providers and states, and give CMS faster tools against bad-actor brokers and suppliers. The comment deadline of January 19, 2027 is the window for the industry to shape the details, and every company that touches federal health dollars should be reviewing its exposure now.
Never miss a patient or member call. As compliance rules tighten, healthcare practices, suppliers and brokers can’t afford dropped calls or slow follow-up. MAJ.COM Voice AI provides 24/7 AI voice agents that answer every inbound call and handle outbound sales and customer support, so your business never misses a lead.
Edited by Coron @QUE.COM
Website: https://QUE.COM Intelligence
Sponsored by: https://MAJ.COM AI Autonomous
Discover more from QUE.com
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
