Commercial Real Estate Sales Plunge 51% in October as Cap Rates Climb, Office and Retail Lending Dries Up, and REITs Beat Private Funds to the Repricing

The commercial real estate recovery that built momentum through the summer hit a wall in October. Preliminary data from MSCI released Wednesday show U.S. commercial property transaction volume totaled just $35.4 billion last month, down 51% from a year earlier, as Bisnow reported. A day later, the Mortgage Bankers Association said commercial and multifamily loan originations fell in the third quarter, with office, retail and hotel borrowing well behind last year’s pace.

Together, the reports show how quickly higher long-term interest rates are feeding through to property values, deal flow and credit. They also point to a widening gap between how public REITs and private real estate funds are pricing the same buildings.

A Strong Third Quarter, Then a Sudden Stall

The October slump stands out because the quarter before it was healthy. According to MSCI’s revised figures, third-quarter transaction volume reached $160.6 billion, up 16% year over year, even without the large mergers and entity-level deals that had inflated volume in earlier months.

A separate third-quarter report from Altus Group, the company behind the widely used Argus software, told a similar story. Altus found dollar volume rose 19.7% from the second quarter and 20.3% from a year earlier, while the number of properties sold climbed 3.8% and 6.9%, respectively. The median price per square foot across all property types increased 2.3% quarter over quarter and 7.8% year over year. Deals of $10 million or more made up more than two-thirds of total dollar volume, a sign that capital was concentrating in larger, higher-quality assets. Altus said industrial and office trades led the gains.

Then the rate backdrop shifted. The 10-year Treasury yield pushed above 5% in September, shortly before the Federal Reserve raised its benchmark rate for the first time since 2023, according to Bisnow. JPMorgan analysts noted in a client note Wednesday that December typically accounts for roughly 15% of a full year’s deal activity, leaving some room for a late recovery, but they said the start of the fourth quarter does not look good.

Cap Rates Rise Across the Board

Higher borrowing costs are showing up directly in pricing. MSCI data show the average cap rate on October transactions rose to 6.85%, up 15 basis points from September. By property type:

  • Retail: up 16 basis points to 7.20%, the largest move
  • Office: up 9 basis points to 7.46%
  • Apartments: up 7 basis points to 8.22%
  • Industrial: up 3 basis points to 6.6%

Because a higher cap rate means a lower price for the same income, these moves translate into lower values for sellers. The JPMorgan analysts said buyers and sellers appear to be adjusting quickly to the new rate environment and that property fundamentals still look broadly solid, which suggests this is a repricing problem more than a demand collapse.

Lenders Pull Back From Office, Retail and Hotels

The MBA’s quarterly originations survey, released Thursday, shows commercial and multifamily lending fell 6% from a year earlier and 5% from the second quarter. The declines were concentrated in the property types most exposed to structural and cyclical pressure:

  • Retail loan volume fell 25% year over year, office fell 24%, hotel fell 22% and multifamily slipped 5%.
  • Industrial originations rose 16% and health care rose 19%, the two clear bright spots.

The mix of lenders is shifting too. Loans for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac dropped 36% year over year and CMBS volume fell 10%, while life insurance company lending rose 12%. Compared with the second quarter, CMBS originations fell 29% and bank lending fell 14%, while life insurers increased their lending 20%.

Private credit is moving in to fill gaps. On Nov. 17, MetLife Investment Management announced it had closed $370 million in commitments for an opportunistic real estate debt fund aimed at transitional properties, offering senior and subordinate loans to borrowers that need to reposition assets, refinance debt or ride out market dislocation.

Public REITs Have Repriced. Private Funds Mostly Haven’t.

At Nareit’s REITworld conference in Atlanta this week, analysts highlighted a valuation gap that could shape the next phase of the market, Bisnow reported. In the third quarter, Nareit’s implied cap rate for public REITs averaged 5.7%, while the NCREIF index of private appraisal cap rates averaged just 4.4%, below the 10-year Treasury’s 4.8% average for the quarter. Nareit said it is the first time since at least 2022 that private appraisal cap rates have fallen below the 10-year yield.

Nareit research chief Edward Pierzak argued that private owners appear to be waiting for rates to fall rather than marking assets to market, which slows price discovery, limits liquidity and makes it harder for investors to redeem capital. He added that such gaps have historically closed, and that when they do, REITs tend to outperform private real estate. Evercore’s Steve Sakwa estimated that true private market cap rates are likely 25 to 50 basis points higher than appraisals suggest, depending on the property type.

Public REITs have already absorbed much of the hit. A November study by CenterSquare cited by Bisnow found the 10-year Treasury yield jumped about 85 basis points in the third quarter, lifting average REIT cap rates by 40 basis points, roughly a 7% loss in value. Even so, U.S. equity REITs have returned an average 16.2% so far this year, their best performance since 2021, according to the FTSE Nareit index.

Why It Matters for Business Readers

Deals are getting harder to finance, not impossible. The lending data show money is still available, but it is moving away from agency and CMBS channels and toward life insurers and private debt funds. Borrowers with office, retail or hotel exposure should expect tighter terms and plan refinancings early.

Sellers face a pricing reality check. Rising cap rates across every major asset class mean values set in a lower-rate world may not hold. Owners who need liquidity in the next 12 months may want to price to the current market rather than wait for rates to fall.

The public-private gap is an opportunity. If private appraisals have to catch up with market rates, private fund investors could see markdowns ahead. For buyers with capital, that adjustment could open better entry points in 2027. REITs, meanwhile, may be able to sell assets to private buyers at appraisal-level prices and use the proceeds to pay down debt or buy back stock, as Sakwa suggested.

Industrial and health care stand out. Both sectors drew more lending than a year ago and industrial cap rates barely moved, reinforcing their position as the most resilient corners of commercial property.

The Bottom Line

October’s 51% drop in sales does not by itself mean commercial real estate has rolled over, and a busy December could still rescue part of the quarter. But with cap rates rising, traditional lenders pulling back from weaker property types and private valuations lagging the market, the fourth quarter is shaping up as a period of repricing. Investors who watch where public markets and private lenders are already putting values will be better positioned than those waiting for appraisals to catch up.

Never Miss a Tenant, Buyer or Lender Call

When deals slow down, every inquiry counts. MAJ.COM Voice AI gives real estate firms 24/7 AI voice agents that answer every inbound call and handle outbound sales and customer support, so you never miss a lead.

Edited by Coron @QUE.COM
Website: https://QUE.COM Intelligence
Sponsored by: https://MAJ.COM AI Autonomous


Discover more from QUE.com

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Coron @QUE.COM

Editor at QUE.com Intelligence.

coronquecom has 192 posts and counting.See all posts by coronquecom

Leave a Reply

Connect with

Discover more from QUE.com

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading